Who would have anticipated that Chief Justice John Roberts’ 2023 Year-End Report would affirm the advantages of AI on our legal system?
Highlighting issues to date, Roberts emphasizes the importance of cautiously integrating AI into legal practices, ensuring it promotes justice while respecting fundamental human qualities and ethical norms.
At the same time, Roberts expresses optimism about AI in the law.
- Increased Access to Justice: AI has the potential to greatly expand access to legal information and resources, particularly for individuals with limited means. It can provide guidance on basic legal questions, help with court forms, and offer directions on presenting cases to judges.
- Efficiency in Legal Processes: The introduction of AI in legal can lead to a more efficient handling of cases. It streamlines research, document review, and case management, allowing for a “just, speedy, and inexpensive” resolution of cases, making it possible for the parties and the courts to comply with Rule 1 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.
- Potential in Legal Education and Research: AI has shown promise in legal education, with its ability to perform at a level comparable to passing law school assignments and bar exams. This indicates its utility in supporting legal research and education.
- Enhancement of Courtroom Procedures and Trials: Digitalization and AI can transform how evidence is presented and received in court, leading to more dynamic and interactive trial environments.
- Support in Handling the Vast Amount of Legal Data: AI and digitalization help lawyers and judges manage the increasing volume of electronic discovery materials and legal documentation, making it easier to handle complex cases with extensive evidence.
Though Justice Roberts sees the role of humans as judges to continue,
But with equal confidence I predict that judicial work — particularly at the trial level — will be significantly affected by AI. Those changes will involve not only how judges go about doing their job, but also how they understand the role that AI plays in the cases that come before them.”
There is no way I could have predicted a year ago a year end report from Justice Roberts like this.